min read

The Ultimate Guide on Talent Assessments (includes best tools)

Talent assessments help create A-teams, here's how to determine if talent has what it takes to join yours.

July 25, 2021
Yuma Heymans
December 29, 2023

Talent assessments are the silent navigators guiding organizations through the complex maze of recruitment and development.

As we peer into the future, the landscape of these assessments is undergoing a shift, thanks to the relentless march of technology and a deeper understanding of human potential. This introduction delves into the heart of modern talent assessments, armed with the latest insights, statistics, and industry trends.

In the vanguard of this revolution is Artificial Intelligence (AI), an agent of change that is redefining the boundaries of how we evaluate, select, and nurture talent.

AI is not merely a tool but an architect crafting a new narrative in talent assessments. It promises a future where organizations, armed with AI, don't just evolve; they lead.

As we look towards 2024, AI is set to automate and enhance every step of the talent assessment process, from CV screening to complex personality assessments.

Realistic AI avatars are on the horizon, promising to assess candidates through natural conversations that reveal deeper insights into their capabilities and potential. This is not the distant future; it's the imminent reality that is reshaping the talent landscape, making traditional psychometric approaches obsolete and ushering in a new era of precision and personalization in talent acquisition and development​​.

However, the revolution does not stop at acquisition. AI's influence extends into talent management and development, offering predictive analytics for performance, personalized training programs, and even digital coaching.

The importance of effective talent management is underscored by compelling statistics. A mere 5% of organizations report that their talent management strategies have been very effective at improving company performance. Yet, those that do are overwhelmingly more likely to outperform their competitors, with 99% reporting such an advantage.

Rapid talent allocation emerges as a critical strategy for organizations aiming for outperformance. Only 39% of respondents report their organizations as quick at reallocating talent as priorities shift. However, this agility is associated with a 1.4 times greater likelihood of outperforming competitors.

The role of HR in fostering a positive employee experience is another pivotal factor. Only 37% of respondents believe their HR functions facilitate a positive employee experience effectively. However, those that do report a 1.3 times higher likelihood of organizational outperformance and a 2.7 times higher likelihood of reporting effective talent management. This highlights the critical impact of HR in shaping not just the recruitment process but the overall organizational culture and performance​​.

The 7 step approach to talent assessments

This guide to talent assessments is a comprehensive journey through the evolving landscape of identifying, attracting, and nurturing the right talent for your organization.

With the introduction already setting the stage for the transformative role of AI and the critical importance of effective talent management, let's delve deeper into the practical approaches and strategies that make talent assessments a potent tool in your organizational arsenal.

  1. Understanding the Basics of Talent Assessments
  2. Leveraging Technology in Talent Assessments
  3. Crafting a Comprehensive Assessment Strategy
  4. Emphasizing Fairness and Diversity
  5. Aligning Talent Assessment with Business Strategy
  6. Enhancing Candidate Experience
  7. Measuring the Effectiveness of Your Talent Assessments

1. Understanding the basics of talent assessments

Before we dive into the advanced strategies and technologies, it's crucial to grasp the foundational elements of talent assessments. These assessments come in various forms, from traditional interviews and psychometric tests to innovative game-based assessments and AI-driven analytics. The goal is not just to gauge the skills and qualifications of candidates but also to predict their future performance, cultural fit, and growth potential within the organization.

  • Psychometric Tests: These are designed to measure a candidate's mental capabilities and behavioral style. They include aptitude tests, personality questionnaires, and situational judgment tests.
  • Competency-based Interviews: These focus on past behavior as an indicator of future performance by asking candidates to describe how they've handled specific work scenarios.
  • Assessment Centers: These involve a combination of activities and exercises that simulate the job environment, helping assess multiple dimensions of a candidate's abilities.
  • Technical Assessments: For roles requiring specific technical skills, these assessments evaluate the depth and breadth of a candidate's expertise in areas like coding, design, or writing.

2. Leveraging technology in talent assessments

The rise of AI and machine learning has revolutionized talent assessments, making them more efficient, accurate, and unbiased. Here's how technology is shaping the future of talent evaluation:

  • AI in Resume Screening: AI algorithms can quickly analyze thousands of resumes, assessing candidates based on experience, skills, and education, and predict their suitability for the role.
  • Game-Based Assessments: These are interactive tests that measure cognitive abilities, problem-solving skills, and personality traits in a more engaging way than traditional assessments.
  • Video Interviews: AI-powered video interview platforms can analyze candidates' language, tone, and facial expressions to assess their personality and emotional intelligence.
  • Predictive Analytics: By analyzing historical data, AI can predict future job performance, helping organizations make more informed hiring decisions.

3. Crafting a comprehensive assessment strategy

A well-rounded talent assessment strategy is vital for obtaining a holistic view of each candidate. It should combine various tools and techniques to measure not just the skills and experience but also the potential for growth and cultural fit.

  • Define the Competencies: Clearly define the skills, knowledge, and attributes that are critical for success in the role and the organization.
  • Choose the Right Tools: Select a combination of assessment tools that best evaluate the defined competencies.
  • Structured Interviews: Develop a standardized set of questions that all candidates are asked, ensuring a fair and consistent assessment process.
  • Continuous Improvement: Regularly review and update your assessment tools and strategy to ensure they remain effective and unbiased.

4. Emphasizing fairness and diversity

In today's globalized world, it's crucial to ensure that your talent assessments promote diversity and prevent bias. This is not just a moral imperative but also a strategic one, as diverse teams are more innovative and perform better.

  • Unbiased Language: Use neutral language in job descriptions and assessments to avoid deterring any group of candidates.
  • Blind Hiring Practices: Consider anonymizing resumes and using AI to conduct initial screenings to focus on skills and competencies rather than demographic characteristics.
  • Diversity in Assessment Panels: Include diverse panel members in interviews and assessments to provide different perspectives and reduce unconscious bias.

5. Aligning talent assessment with business strategy

The ultimate goal of talent assessments is to drive organizational success. This means they should be closely aligned with your overall business strategy.

  • Understand Business Goals: Ensure that the competencies you're assessing for are aligned with your organization's current and future strategic goals.
  • Predictive Success Modeling: Use data from past assessments and employee performance to predict how well candidates will perform in your specific organizational context.
  • Feedback Loop: Create a system where assessment outcomes are continuously compared against actual job performance, providing insights to refine future assessments.

6. Enhancing candidate experience

The way you assess candidates not only determines who joins your team but also impacts your employer brand. A positive assessment experience can enhance your reputation and attract top talent.

  • Clear Communication: Keep candidates informed about the process, what to expect, and the timelines involved.
  • Respectful Interactions: Ensure every interaction with the candidate is professional and respectful, reflecting your organization's values.
  • Feedback: Provide constructive feedback to candidates, regardless of the outcome, to help them in their career journey.

7. Measuring the effectiveness of your talent assessments

To ensure your talent assessment process remains effective, it's crucial to regularly measure and analyze its outcomes.

  • Quality of Hire: Track metrics such as performance ratings, tenure, and upward mobility of new hires to assess the quality of your assessment process.
  • Candidate Feedback: Collect feedback from candidates on their assessment experience to identify areas for improvement.
  • ROI Analysis: Calculate the return on investment of your talent assessment process by comparing the costs involved against the benefits, such as reduced turnover and improved performance.

The best talent assessment tools

Without the right tools it's very hard to assess talent in a data-driven, objective and efficient way.

This list showcases the best talent assessment tools available, each designed to offer a unique approach to streamline the hiring process, enhance candidate understanding, and predict job performance with greater accuracy.

  1. HireVue
  2. Pymetrics
  3. Criteria Corp
  4. Talent Q
  5. Berke
  6. Plum
  7. The Predictive Index
  8. TestGorilla
  9. HireLogic
  10. Spark Hire

1. HireVue

HireVue is a renowned video interviewing and talent assessment platform that leverages AI to help companies identify the best candidates. It's designed to streamline the hiring process, offering a more comprehensive understanding of candidates beyond their resumes.

Price: Custom pricing based on the needs of the organization.

Free Trial: Yes, HireVue offers a demo upon request.

G2 Rating: 4.1/5

Key Feature: Its AI-driven assessments provide deep insights into candidates' soft skills and potential performance.

Best for: SMB to Enterprise, with scalable solutions for different business sizes.

Great for Recruiters Because: It allows recruiters to conduct more interviews in less time while gaining deeper behavioral insights, making the selection process more efficient and predictive.

2. Pymetrics

Pymetrics applies neuroscience and AI to the recruitment process, providing games-based assessments that predict candidate's fit for various roles.

Price: Custom pricing available upon request.

Free Trial: Not typically offered, but demo requests are possible.

G2 Rating: 3.5/5

Key Feature: Unique games-based approach to assess cognitive and emotional traits.

Best for: Mid-market to Enterprise, especially those looking for innovative assessment methods.

Great for Recruiters Because: It offers a more engaging candidate experience and helps reduce unconscious bias, leading to more diverse and suitable hires.

3. Criteria Corp

Criteria Corp is a leading talent success platform that provides objective, multidimensional assessments to organizations worldwide.

Price: Custom pricing available upon request.

Free Trial: Yes, a free trial is available.

G2 Rating: 4.5/5

Key Feature: Offers a comprehensive suite of assessments that cover aptitude, personality, and skills.

Best for: SMB to Mid-market.

Great for Recruiters Because: It helps streamline the hiring process with easy-to-understand reports and benchmarks tailored to specific positions, enhancing the quality of hire.

4. Talent Q

Talent Q is part of Korn Ferry and offers a range of assessments designed to identify potential and pinpoint development areas.

Price: Varies based on the services and volume of use.

Free Trial: Information on trials is not publicly available, but you can request a demo.

G2 Rating: 4.0/5

Key Feature: Their assessments are adaptive, meaning questions adjust to the candidate's ability, providing a precise measure of their skills.

Best for: Mid-market to Enterprise.

Great for Recruiters Because: The adaptive nature of the assessments ensures a deeper and more accurate understanding of each candidate's abilities, facilitating better matching for positions.

5. Berke

Berke is a job and talent assessment tool that uses data-driven methodologies to help companies understand how candidates will behave and perform in various job roles.

Price: Pricing varies based on the volume and type of assessments used.

Free Trial: Yes, Berke offers a free trial to prospective clients.

G2 Rating: 4.6/5

Key Feature: Offers customized assessments tailored to the specific attributes of each job within your company.

Best for: SMB to Mid-market looking for customized assessment solutions.

Great for Recruiters Because: It provides detailed insights into candidates' personality traits and abilities, helping to predict job performance and ensuring a good job fit.

6. Plum

Plum combines industrial/organizational psychology and AI to provide predictive talent data, helping companies hire, grow, and retain top talents.

Price: Custom pricing based on company size and needs.

Free Trial: Available upon request.

G2 Rating: 4.5/5

Key Feature: Unique in its ability to quantify company culture and match candidates based on cultural fit and job requirements.

Best for: SMB to Enterprise, especially those looking to align talent strategy with business strategy.

Great for Recruiters Because: It not only helps in the selection process but also guides development and workforce planning with its deep, predictive insights.

7. The Predictive Index

The Predictive Index offers a talent optimization platform that helps businesses align their people strategy with their business strategy for optimal results.

Price: Custom pricing is available upon request.

Free Trial: No standard free trial, but demonstrations are available.

G2 Rating: 4.5/5

Key Feature: Known for its Behavioral Assessment and cognitive ability assessment, providing a comprehensive look at workplace behaviors and aptitudes.

Best for: Mid-market to Enterprise, especially those focused on strategic workforce planning.

Great for Recruiters Because: It helps in not only recruiting the right people but also in managing and inspiring them effectively, aligning talent with business needs.

8. TestGorilla

TestGorilla is a pre-employment testing software designed to help companies make better hiring decisions faster and bias-free. It offers a wide array of tests covering various skills and industries to assess candidates comprehensively.

Price: TestGorilla operates on a tiered pricing model with options ranging from free for basic features to custom pricing for advanced needs.

Free Trial: A free plan is available, and paid plans offer a free trial period.

G2 Rating: 4..5/5

Key Feature: Provides a diverse range of over 150 scientifically validated tests, from cognitive ability and personality to software skills and job-specific tasks.

Best for: SMB to Enterprise, particularly beneficial for those looking to screen candidates quickly and effectively across a wide range of job roles.

Great for Recruiters Because: It enables recruiters to objectively compare candidates with comprehensive, easy-to-understand scoring, helping to eliminate bias and identify the best talent based on proven competencies.

9. HireLogic

HireLogic is an intelligent interview platform that uses AI to help organizations make objective, data-driven hiring decisions. It provides insights into candidates' skills, personality, and fit through advanced natural language processing and other AI technologies.

Price: Pricing details are customized based on the organization's size and specific needs.

Free Trial: Information about a free trial is not readily available, but interested parties can contact them for a demo.

G2 Rating: Not available; however, it's recommended to check the latest ratings directly on G2 or similar platforms.

Key Feature: Its AI-driven insights offer a deeper analysis of candidates' responses and behaviors during interviews, providing a more nuanced understanding of their potential.

Best for: Mid-market to Enterprise, particularly suitable for organizations looking to enhance their interview processes with AI-driven analytics.

Great for Recruiters Because: It automates the interview analysis process, allowing recruiters to focus on the human aspect of hiring while relying on data to make informed decisions.

10. Spark Hire

Spark Hire is a video interviewing platform that enables organizations to improve their hiring process with one-way and live video interviews. It's designed to streamline candidate screening and enhance collaboration among hiring teams.

Price: Spark Hire offers several pricing plans, including a pay-per-interview option and monthly subscriptions tailored to different organizational needs.

Free Trial: A demo is available upon request, and there may be trial options for certain plans.

G2 Rating: 4.7/5

Key Feature: Offers a convenient and efficient one-way video interview feature, allowing candidates to answer questions on their own time and hiring teams to review at their convenience.

Best for: SMB to Enterprise, with scalable solutions that fit various hiring volumes and processes.

Great for Recruiters Because: It significantly reduces the time spent on preliminary interviews and enhances the collaborative decision-making process, making it easier to identify the top candidates early on.

More content like this

Sign up and receive the best new tech recruiting content weekly.
Thank you! Fresh tech recruiting content coming your way 🧠
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Latest Articles

Candidates hired on autopilot

Get qualified and interested candidates in your mailbox with zero effort.

1 billion reach
Automated recruitment
Save 95% time